Sculptural installations can fail for a variety of reasons — some site specific works are not built to accommodate changing conditions, others are scorned by the community (see Richard Serra’s Tilted Arc), and finally, there is a category of works that are just plain dangerous. This week I’m counting down 5 art installation disasters, mishaps and failures.
1. Christo and Jeanne-Claude: The curse of The Umbrellas
International artists Christo and Jeanne-Claude, famous for controversial large scale environmental works, including The Gates in NYC’s Central Park, had a multitude of problems with their Umbrellas installations in October 1991.
Simultaneously appearing in both Southern California (Tejon Pass) and Ibaraki, Japan, Christo and Jeanne-Claude installed 1,760, 485-pound yellow umbrellas and 1,340, 485-pound blue umbrellas, respectively.
The umbrellas were a welcome and unexpected addition to both landscapes, but the artists underestimated the volatile wind in Southern California’s Grapevine. Despite having been wind tunnel tested to withstand gusts of 65 mph, a 40 mph+ gale lifted an umbrella, crushing a spectator against a boulder.
Out of respect, Christo and Jeanne-Claude had both pieces removed at the end of October. Coincidentally, while disassembling the Japanese installation, a crane operator was electrocuted when he inadvertently touched a high-voltage power line. From christojeanclaude.net:
After 18 days, The Umbrellas were removed from the land. They were taken apart and most of the materials were recycled. The paint was scraped off the aluminum parts, (poles, ribs and struts) which was melted down and used again as aluminum. like soda cans or whatever aluminum is used for. The steel bases became scrap metal or were used as bases for satellite dishes. The fabric used in the projects is always industrial man made fabrics, which are manufactured for ecological purposes (air and water filters, or sand bags against floods), or agricultural purposes, such as “erosion control mesh” which was used for the Wrapped Coast in Australia in 1969, and for construction purposes.
More on the incidents from NYT.